Ministry rebuts accusations of ‘hostage justice’ in Japan
The Justice Ministry published explanatory information about the nation’s justice system on its website on Tuesday, rebutting international criticism of Japan’s prosecutorial approach.
The system has been described as “hostage justice,” most particularly in the wake of former Nissan Motor Co. Chairman Carlos Ghosn’s flight from the country following his prolonged detention.
The explanatory information is offered as 14 sets of questions and answers, and is available in both Japanese and English.
In a question about arguments claiming Japan’s system is a form of hostage justice, the ministry said the system “does not force confessions by unduly holding suspects and defendants in custody.”
On a question about whether suspects are held in custody for extended periods, the ministry said the maximum period of detainment after their arrest before they are indicted or not is 23 days for any single crime.
The ministry also said, “The detention of an indicted person is granted only if a court (judge) finds a risk of concealing or destroying evidence of crime, or fleeing from justice.” It added, “Bail may be granted by a court (judge) unless exceptional circumstances apply, such as the existence of a risk of concealing or destroying evidence by the indicted.”
“In short, suspects and defendants will be held in custody only for a necessary and reasonable duration under Japanese criminal proceedings,” it said.
The 3,000-word list of questions and answers also addresses Japan’s conviction rate of more than 99 percent, and why lawyers are not present during questioning.
Ghosn, who had been released on bail, fled over the New Year holidays while awaiting trial on charges that included underreporting income. He has denied all the charges against him. He said he had no choice but to run and that he felt “like the hostage of a country I served for 17 years.”
His complaints were echoed by Australian sports journalist Scott McIntyre, who was detained at the same facility as Ghosn for 44 days on trespassing charges after he tried to get information about his missing children.